For me, the answer with questions like these (Beatles vs stones, Oasis vs Blur) has always been 'yes' or 'no' rather than one or other of the bands. I am tiresome snowflake boy in that regard. The reason I mentioned those two LPs is because I care for both, for instance.

The answer to a different question would be 'I'd rather be in a Stooges cover band.'

Urg. Thinking too hard.